I wonder how many of you heard the piece on the Today programme where Liz O’Neal from the Vegetarian Society stated that we should all be veggie/vegan to help climate change as farm animals produce more methane than the airline industry. The interview was prompted by a leaked email from the Environment Agency to a vegetarian campaign group.
It took the headlines in the South West’s daily paper the Western Morning News – ‘Vegans Hijack Climate Debate’. And has caused outcry amongst the farming community and shadow ministers.
So what do I think? Well, I’m horrified of course - I’m a beef farmer.
But isn’t this what climate change is all about? Isn’t it going to affect all our lives in every way? Instead of hiding our heads in the sand, we should look the beast in the eyes and begin to make changes.
There have been many studies done on the impact farming has, not just on the immediate environment, but also the global environment. These have shown that cattle are a major source of concern and are one of the chief contributors to global warming through methane emissions.
Where do we go from here?
I believe that we have to look at producing cheap, safe food for the entire planet but not at the expense of all else. I don’t think this means that the planet should give up eating meat, but should think twice about consuming the huge quantities of intensively reared animals it does at present (I’m not even going to touch on animal welfare issues here).
With science and technology surging forward in leaps and bounds it should soon be possible to ‘grow’ the ubiquitous ‘chicken breast’ or ‘beefburger’ in a controlled environment using micro organisms, hopefully with far less impact on the climate. But until then, surely we farmers should think carefully about how we affect Earth’s future and do what we can to make that more secure.


11 comments
Comments feed for this article
June 1, 2007 at 11:55 am
Sara
Hi Paula,
What an interesting and thought provoking issue. Definately food for thought!
Sara from farmingfriends in Yorkshire
June 1, 2007 at 10:26 pm
paula
Hi Sara,
You’re so right…it certainly is!
June 6, 2007 at 6:36 pm
Phil Luke
Unfortunately the veggie lobby cannot see much beyond their immediate noses. There sometimes seems to be a view that if something is good, then even more of it is much better, which is rarely the case. We need a wide range of habitats for our wildlife to survive and grassland is an essential part of this biodiversity which requires grazing animals to maintain it.
As you suggest, we could eat a lot less meat and so reduce the animal methane production, but for EVERYONE to become vegetarian/vegan I would suggest is too extreme and therefore ecologically unstable. We need diversity and balance in all things.
June 11, 2007 at 8:40 am
paula
We’ve been away in Scotland for a week and come back to a farm devoid of any outside communication…now we wait patiently for BT to fix it! So apologies for the delay in replying.
I agree, Phil, we need diversity and balance as a rule, though now the earth is out of kilter I feel our actions should reflect this.
This doesn’t mean I’m advocating total vegan/veggie-ism for the world!
June 11, 2007 at 11:30 am
Nigel Smith
The vegetarians are barking up the wrong tree here (no pun intended)!
Pseudo-scientists will jump on anything to back their claims about Global Warming.
Take it from me, having written scientific articles for Wikipedia on climate change, methane producing land mammals are not the ‘danger’ that the vegetarians make them to be. Yes methane does contribute towards climate change, but the levels produced are insiginficant to anthropogenic carbon emissions.
I have discussed the whole matter of methanogenesis with others and can reassure the general public that far from being a problem, dairy and beef farming will become extremely useful for microgeneration of domestic gas supplies.
It has been postulated that the future trend of agriculture will be towards energy crops, to produce bio-diesel, ethanol and biodigested methane, whilst traditional farmers will tend to produce more organic foods. Not just to satisfy growing demand, but also to reduce the number of ‘air-miles’ that basic staple food has to travel.
LOCAL FOOD IS BEST - is a motto that is very true. Some supermarkets are advertising that their ‘local’ produce has come from less than 30 miles away. Not only does this pump money back into the local economy, but the food is fresher and better quality. British agriculture can supply quality products and in Paula’s farm we have some of the finest beef I have ever tasted. Long may she continue to rear the finest cattle in the country.
June 12, 2007 at 8:50 am
paula
Some very interesting and thought provoking points, Nigel. I look forward to the responses.
And thank you for your support and encouragement for the way I farm.
July 1, 2007 at 2:37 am
jeanette
in time past we had the prophets telling all who would listen that unless we kept gods rule of law our land and all who dwelt there in would suffer- if you go back even further CAIN killed ABLE was CAIN the first vegaterian?there are more deserts made by ploughing then grazing
July 20, 2007 at 5:09 pm
Phil Luke
There is an article in New Scientist on a study which has assessed the effects of beef production on global warming, water acidification and eutrophication, and energy consumption at:
http://environment.newscientist.com/article/mg19526134.500?DCMP=NLC-nletter&nsref=mg19526134.500
However, an interesting comment in the article is that: “A Swedish study in 2003 suggested that organic beef, raised on grass rather than concentrated feed, emits 40 per cent less greenhouse gases and consumes 85 per cent less energy.”
July 21, 2007 at 11:48 am
paula
Thank you. Yes, I’ve read the article too, Phil (I live in a house full of scientist).
It would be interesting to compare intensively reared stock with beef from ‘conventional’ farming methods (beef that is summer reared on nitrogen rye grass and fed substantial quantities of cake). A comparison between conventional methods and organic would also be useful to know. I don’t believe there’s been any proper research done on this to date.
Have you found any?
March 9, 2008 at 2:07 am
jemima
what climate do farm animals live in?
March 9, 2008 at 9:38 pm
paula
Thank you for your comment jemima; I’m not entirely sure what you mean by your question.
Are you interested in cattle and climate change or cattle habitat? If you could clarify I’d be pleased to answer as best I can.